Part 5 of “The Newsprint Vultures” — The legislative attempts, regulatory gaps, and why every attempt to constrain hedge fund newspaper ownership has failed.
The letter that got no response
On February 21, 2019, Senator Chuck Schumer of New York sent a letter to Heath Freeman, the president of Alden Global Capital.[1]
Schumer was concerned. Alden had announced an unsolicited bid to acquire Gannett — the largest newspaper chain in America. The hedge fund already owned MediaNews Group (Digital First Media) with a reputation for deep cuts. Now it wanted to add USA Today and more than 100 local papers to its portfolio.
Schumer’s letter was specific. He asked:
- Did Alden intend to sell or lease Gannett’s real estate properties?
- What were Alden’s plans for journalist staffing and newsroom commitments?
- What would happen to Gannett’s pension plans?
- Were there antitrust concerns that required Department of Justice review?
The response: Alden did not provide a public response. The Gannett acquisition ultimately failed. But the pattern — a hedge fund extracting value while federal officials watched — continued.[2]
The regulatory gaps
Alden’s model is legal. That’s the fundamental problem.
What’s prohibited:
- Directly stealing pension funds (ERISA violation)
- Lying to investors (securities fraud)
- Falsifying financial statements (accounting fraud)
What’s permitted:
- Transferring pension assets into affiliated investments (if disclosed)
- Charging management fees for “services” to subsidiaries
- Selling subsidiary real estate to related entities
- Cutting staff until profitability improves
- Using debt-financed acquisitions
Alden’s techniques sit in the permitted category. The pension transfers were disclosed (poorly), the management fees were charged for actual services (of questionable value), the real estate was sold at market rates (after being transferred to an affiliate).
Each technique, individually, passes legal muster. Only the combination — the full extraction playbook — reveals the pattern. And pattern-based regulation is nearly impossible to enforce.
The state-level attempts
New York City Council Resolution 1015-2025
In October 2025, the New York City Council passed Resolution 1015-2025, titled “Too Tough to Die.”[3]
The resolution:
- Condemned Alden Global Capital for cuts and “managerial hostility” toward unionized Daily News staff
- Called on the hedge fund to reach a contract deal with the newspaper’s union
- Noted that the Daily News staff had been reduced to 54 full-time journalists for a city of 8.5 million residents
- Highlighted three years of stalled contract negotiations
The status: Passed. But resolutions aren’t laws. They express sentiment without creating enforcement mechanisms.
Connecticut Senate Bill 1043 (2021)
Connecticut tried something stronger. When Alden acquired the Hartford Courant — America’s oldest continuously published newspaper, founded in 1764 — state legislators introduced SB 1043.[4]
The bill would have:
- Barred newspaper owners from incurring debt “not in the public interest”
- Prohibited dividend distributions that could threaten newspaper viability
- Required owners to maintain minimum newsroom staffing levels
The outcome: A hearing was held in March 2021. Penelope Abernathy, the Medill researcher who coined the term “news desert,” testified that hedge fund owners “lack an appreciation for journalism’s traditional civic mission” and “view their newspapers as investments to be bought, sold, traded or shuttered.”[5]
But the bill faced constitutional challenges. The newspaper association argued that state regulation of newspaper ownership violated the First Amendment. The bill never advanced to a vote.
Connecticut Attorney General Investigation
Connecticut Attorney General William Tong opened an antitrust investigation into Alden’s Tribune Publishing acquisition.[6]
The concerns:
- Whether the acquisition would reduce competition in local news markets
- Whether Alden’s ownership structure violated antitrust principles
- Whether pension funds were being properly managed
The outcome: No public resolution. No public resolution was announced from the investigation after Alden completed the acquisition.
The federal response (or lack thereof)
The Journalism Competition and Preservation Act
Senator Amy Klobuchar (D-MN) and Senator John Kennedy (R-LA) introduced the Journalism Competition and Preservation Act (JCPA) in 2023.[7]
The bill would:
- Allow news organizations to collectively negotiate with Google and Facebook for compensation
- Create an antitrust exemption for news outlets to band together
- Redirect advertising revenue from platforms to newsrooms
The problem: The JCPA addresses platform power, not hedge fund extraction. It would help newspapers earn more from advertising, but it wouldn’t prevent owners from siphoning that revenue into affiliated investments.
The status: Reintroduced in the 118th Congress. No floor vote. No enacted version.
No Federal Hedge Fund Regulation
There is no federal law specifically regulating hedge fund ownership of newspapers.
The Federal Trade Commission can review mergers for antitrust concerns — but Alden’s acquisitions have mostly been of distressed newspapers, not mergers that reduce competition.
The Department of Labor can investigate ERISA violations — but the 2019 pension settlement showed that enforcement results in modest penalties without admissions of wrongdoing.
The Securities and Exchange Commission can require disclosures — but Alden’s disclosures, however inadequate, passed minimum requirements.
The structural problem
Why can’t regulators stop the extraction?
Jurisdictional gaps:
- Pension transfers fall under the Department of Labor (ERISA)
- Real estate sales fall under state corporate law
- Management fees are contractual
- Staffing cuts have no regulatory framework
Each extraction technique operates in a different legal silo. No single agency sees the pattern.
Enforcement delays:
- The DOL investigation took years
- The settlement included no admission of wrongdoing
- Monitoring (Cambridge Associates) was required only after the fact
Regulatory capture:
- Hedge funds have sophisticated legal teams
- Corporate structures create distance between parent and subsidiary
- “Not technically illegal” is a defense that works
The worker perspective
Rebecca Lurye, the Hartford Courant Guild chair (union representative), testified before the Connecticut legislature in March 2021:[8]
“I’m writing because America’s longest continuously published newspaper is under attack, its survival threatened by far-off corporate leaders who are diminishing the vital journalism we produce in their pursuit of the next penny.”
The Courant had been publishing since 1764 — before the United States existed. It survived the Revolution, the Civil War, the Industrial Revolution. It couldn’t survive Alden’s extraction.
The workers at Alden-owned newspapers tried legislation, regulation, and public pressure. They signed open letters, testified at hearings, and organized protests. But the mechanisms of extraction — legal, fragmented, and siloed across regulatory jurisdictions — continued.
Why nothing changed
The response to Alden illustrates a larger regulatory problem: financial engineering is legal until it isn’t, and proving harm requires resources that regulators often lack.
Alden’s techniques are:
- Legal in isolation — each technique passes muster
- Effective in combination — the full playbook extracts value
- Hard to regulate — pattern-based enforcement is difficult
- Protected by corporate structure — distance between parent and subsidiary
Regulators face:
- Jurisdictional constraints — no single agency sees the full picture
- Resource limits — investigations take years
- Settlement culture — penalties without admissions
- Constitutional challenges — state laws face First Amendment scrutiny
The newspaper industry’s decline created an opening for financial engineers. Alden stepped into that opening. And the regulatory framework that might have constrained the extraction — antitrust, pension law, corporate governance — wasn’t designed for this specific pattern.
The conclusion
Alden Global Capital didn’t invent hedge fund newspaper ownership. It merely perfected the extraction model: acquire distressed assets at low prices, strip real estate and pension funds, cut newsrooms to the bone, direct profits to the parent portfolio, and leave a hollow brand behind.
The extraction was legal. The regulators were fragmented. The workers were exhausted. The newspapers became shells.
And the democracy toll — the measurable costs in municipal finance, voter participation, and government accountability — continues to accrue.
What this series has documented
- Part 1: The Shell Game — How Alden uses corporate structures (DFM, Twenty Lake Holdings, pension trusts) to extract value while maintaining legal distance.
- Part 2: The Pension Play — How $294 million in employee retirement savings was transferred to Alden-controlled funds, resulting in a $20.7 million settlement but no admission of wrongdoing.
- Part 3: The Profitability Paradox — How DFM showed 17% operating margins while cutting 52% of newsroom staff, directing profits to the InvestmentCO subsidiary.
- Part 4: The Democracy Toll — How newspaper closures increase municipal borrowing costs, decrease voter turnout, and create predictable news deserts.
- Part 5: The Congressional Response — How federal and state regulators have failed to constrain hedge fund extraction, leaving newspapers to face the pattern alone.
The extraction model works. The regulations don’t. And until something changes, the pattern will repeat.
Notes
- Schumer, Charles E., Letter to Heath Freeman, President, Alden Global Capital LLC, February 21, 2019. https://www.schumer.senate.gov/newsroom/press-releases/schumer-demands-new-information-from-alden-global-capital-hedge-fund-known-for-destroying-local-newspapers-and-slashing-jobs-across-the-country-including-5-upstate-ny-papers-regarding-their-efforts-to-acquire-gannett-and-the-potential-free-speech-and-pension-stability-implications-of-such-a-takeover
- The Gannett acquisition ultimately failed; Alden later acquired Tribune Publishing.
- New York City Council, Resolution 1015-2025, “Resolution condemning Alden Global Capital cuts and managerial hostility towards unionized Daily News staff,” adopted October 29, 2025. https://nyc.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?ID=7514148&GUID=C0975B64-E104-4E00-9099-D8AAC2FF7865
- Connecticut General Assembly, Public Hearing, Insurance and Real Estate Committee, Senate Bill 1043, March 18, 2021.
- Abernathy, Penelope, testimony before Connecticut Insurance and Real Estate Committee, March 2021. DFM Workers coverage: https://dfmworkers.org/connecticut-bill-aims-to-block-hartford-courants-hedge-fund-owners-from-making-moves-not-in-the-public-interest/
- Hartford Courant, “Connecticut Attorney General pressing New York hedge fund Alden Global for information about proposed takeover of Hartford Courant parent company Tribune Publishing,” January 28, 2021.
- Senator Amy Klobuchar, “Klobuchar, Kennedy Introduce Bipartisan Legislation To Save Local Journalism,” press release, March 2023.
- Lurye, Rebecca, written testimony, Connecticut General Assembly, March 2021.
This concludes “The Newsprint Vultures,” a five-part investigation into the financial destruction of local journalism by Alden Global Capital.