Part 4 of “The Newsprint Vultures” — The measurable costs to communities when newspapers close: higher borrowing costs, lower voter turnout, and diminished accountability.
The numbers, updated
In 2025, the Medill School of Journalism at Northwestern University released its latest State of Local News report. The numbers had worsened:[1]
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Counties with zero news sources | 213 (up from 206 in 2024) |
| Counties with only one news source | 1,524 |
| Americans with limited/no local news | 50 million |
| Newspaper closures this year | 136 (2+ per week) |
The industry had lost more than three-quarters of its newspaper jobs since 2005 — a 76% collapse over 20 years.[2] And the rate was accelerating: more than two newspapers closing every week.
Most Americans experience this as absence. They open a newspaper website and find it hasn’t been updated. They search for coverage of a city council meeting and find nothing. They notice that no one has investigated the local school board in years.
But the costs are measurable — and they’re measured in dollars, not just in civic sentiment.
The municipal bond penalty
In 2020, three economists — Pengjie Gao, Chang Lee, and Dermot Murphy — published a study in the Journal of Financial Economics with a striking title: “Financing Dies in Darkness? The Impact of Newspaper Closures on Public Finance.”[3]
The finding: Research has found that when a local newspaper closes, municipal borrowing costs are associated with increases of by 5 to 11 basis points.
The translation: For a county issuing bonds, that’s an additional $650,000 in interest costs per bond issue.
The mechanism: Without a local newspaper investigating government finances, bond investors demand higher yields to compensate for increased uncertainty. They can’t verify whether the mayor is honest, whether the budget is accurate, whether the infrastructure projects are real.
The study quantified what local officials had long suspected: newspapers weren’t just watchdogs. They were financial infrastructure. When they closed, borrowing costs went up — and taxpayers paid the difference.
It wasn’t theoretical. The research covered actual bond issuances before and after newspaper closures, controlling for economic conditions. The effect was real, measurable, and persistent.
The voter turnout correlation
The Gao study looked at money. But what about votes?
Lauren Pennington, in a University of Nebraska-Lincoln thesis, examined the relationship between news deserts and voter turnout.[4] Using county-level data from Nebraska, she tested whether losing local news correlated with decreased political participation.
The finding: As counties lost access to local news — measured through newspaper closures and circulation decline — voter turnout decreased accordingly.
The significance: The relationship was statistically significant, though the thesis noted that correlating factors like demographic changes could also influence turnout. Counties that became news deserts saw measurable drops in voter participation.
The mechanism is intuitive. Without local news coverage, residents have less information about local candidates, ballot measures, and government performance. They may still vote in national elections, but local turnout suffers.
The Nebraska study wasn’t definitive proof of causation — but it added to a growing body of research suggesting that local journalism’s decline has electoral consequences.
The predictive model
The Medill report included something new: a risk model.[5]
Using data on newspaper closures, demographic trends, and economic indicators, researchers identified 250 counties at high risk of becoming news deserts over the next decade.
These weren’t random. They shared characteristics:
- Declining newspaper circulation
- Aging populations
- Lower median incomes
- Distance from metropolitan news centers
The model is grimly practical: if you can predict where newspapers will close, you can predict where democracy will thin. And the prediction is that 250 more counties will lose their last news source in the next ten years.
What’s lost
Alden cut 52% of newsroom staff between 2012 and 2017. The workers who remained tried to cover the beats — but the beats multiplied.
One reporter covering city hall. One reporter covering schools. One reporter covering courts, crime, business, features, and everything else. The idea of an “investigative team” became nostalgic. The notion of a reporter who could spend weeks on a single story? Gone.
What doesn’t get covered:
- City council meetings — Who watches the zoning decisions, the contract votes, the hiring decisions?
- School boards — Who tracks curriculum changes, budget allocations, teacher contracts?
- Local courts — Who covers the trials that don’t make national news?
- Municipal finance — Who reads the bond offerings, the pension obligations, the infrastructure contracts?
What fills the vacuum:
- Patched-together coverage — Regional outlets sending reporters from distant cities
- Social media — Unverified claims, partisan framing, engagement-driven algorithms
- Nothing — The beat simply goes unwatched
The democracy toll is cumulative. Each closure removes a set of eyes. Each staff reduction narrows the field of vision. And the communities least able to compensate — the ones with aging populations, lower incomes, geographic isolation — are the ones most affected.
The local exception
There’s a counter-argument: national news is more accessible than ever. Americans can read The New York Times, watch CNN, listen to NPR. Why does local coverage matter?
Because local news covers local power. National outlets cover the president, Congress, the Supreme Court. They don’t cover the county commission, the school board, the city zoning board. And those bodies have direct effects on daily life.
What local newspapers do that national outlets can’t:
- Attend every city council meeting
- Review every development proposal
- Track every police disciplinary case
- Cover every high school graduation
- Report on every local business scandal
The national media ecosystem has no substitute for this. It’s not that Americans don’t have enough news. It’s that they don’t have enough local news — and there’s no national fix for that.
The financial argument
Municipal bond costs increase. Voter turnout decreases. Government efficiency declines. These are measurable, empirical effects — and they have dollar values.
The Gao study quantified the bond premium. The Nebraska study quantified the turnout effect. Researchers are still quantifying the other costs:
- Government wages — increase when newspapers close, according to follow-up research[6]
- Public procurement competitiveness — decreases
- Local government efficiency — declines
The financial case for local journalism isn’t just about preserving newspapers as businesses. It’s about the downstream costs when they fail.
What comes next
Part 5: The Congressional Response — Why regulators have failed to stop the extraction.
Alden’s model is legal. The pension transfers might have violated ERISA, but they resulted in a settlement, not prosecution. The real estate stripping is standard corporate practice. The management fees are unregulated. And no law prevents a hedge fund from buying newspapers and cutting them to the bone.
The question isn’t just why Alden did it. The question is why it was allowed.
Notes
- Medill School of Journalism, “News deserts hit new high and 50 million have limited access to local news,” Northwestern University press release, 2025. https://www.medill.northwestern.edu/news/2025/news-deserts-hit-new-high-and-50-million-have-limited-access-to-local-news-study-finds.html
- Medill School of Journalism, State of Local News Report 2025, Northwestern University, 2025.
- Gao, Pengjie, Chang Lee, and Dermot Murphy, “Financing Dies in Darkness? The Impact of Newspaper Closures on Public Finance,” Journal of Financial Economics 135, no. 2 (2020): 445-467. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0304405X19301606
- Pennington, Lauren, “News Deserts And Voter Turnout: How Local News Shortages Decrease Voter Participation,” University of Nebraska-Lincoln Honors Thesis, March 25, 2024. https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/honorstheses/672/
- Medill School of Journalism, State of Local News Report 2025, predictive risk modeling section.
- ResearchGate summary, “Financing Dies in Darkness? The Impact of Newspaper Closures on Public Finance,” describing follow-up research on government wages and procurement. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/333778464_Financing_Dies_in_Darkness_The_Impact_of_Newspaper_Closures_on_Public_Finance
This article is part of the “Newsprint Vultures” series, investigating the financial destruction of local journalism. Part 5 examines the regulatory failures that allowed the extraction to continue.