The Competence Principle
What the Founders Expected, What Courts Have Allowed, and Why Screening Works
Part 1 identified three rationales for the Second Amendment: political, civic, and individual. Each envisions armed capability, not mere armed possession. The Minnesota neighborhood guards demonstrated that the civic and political rationales are still alive—citizens will step forward to protect their communities when institutions fail. They did exactly what the Framers intended: pro-social, community-supporting armed defense. But they were ad hoc, untrained, unorganized. The gap between the Founders’ aspiration and American practice is the space this series inhabits. When a significant portion of the population is armed, equipped, and capable, anyone who wants to abuse them must think twice. When that population is armed but untrained, the deterrent is real but degraded, and the costs—accidents, negligence, adolescent access—fall on the community. Improving the “regulation” would lead to more and better examples like Minnesota.
The Founders aspired to competence. The Second Amendment opens with a qualification: “A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State.”[1] Gun rights advocates have spent decades arguing that the prefatory clause means nothing—that “the right of the people to keep and bear Arms” stands alone. Gun control advocates have argued the opposite: that the militia reference limits the right to collective military service. Both miss the point. The prefatory clause describes the purpose; the operative clause protects the right. The phrase “well regulated” is not a limitation on the right—it is a description of what makes the right function as intended.
In eighteenth-century usage, “well regulated” meant properly functioning—drilled, equipped, and disciplined.[3] A “well regulated” militia was not an unorganized mass of individuals with guns. It was a body capable of effective action. The constitutional structure envisions capability. Whether that vision translates into a requirement for pre-purchase competence certification is a question the series cannot answer deductively—it must be argued from evidence, history, and practical consequence.
This expectation was not abstract. The Militia Act of 1792 required enrolled militiamen to own specified arms and to appear for training when called.[4] The federal government lacked the resources to train every able-bodied white male, but states maintained militia systems with varying degrees of seriousness. The expectation of competence was embedded in the constitutional structure.
The historical record is messier than either side typically acknowledges. The Militia Act was widely ignored in practice; colonial and early American musters were often social events rather than serious military training.[5] By the War of 1812, militia performance against British regulars was sufficiently poor that the federal government began building a professional army. The “well regulated” ideal was never fully realized. But the expectation that the right came with responsibilities—training, equipment, readiness—was real.
—
State Courts Understood the Right
Before Heller settled the federal question in 2008, state courts interpreting nearly identical language in their own constitutions had already found individual rights to keep and bear arms—often with explicit competence expectations attached.
In Nunn v. State (1846), the Georgia Supreme Court struck down a law prohibiting the carrying of pistols. The court held that the Second Amendment protected an individual right, and that “the right of the whole people, old and young, men, women and boys, and not militia only, to keep and bear arms of every description, and not such merely as are used by the militia, shall not be infringed, curtailed, or broken in upon.”[6] But the court also upheld the state’s prohibition on concealed carry, finding that the manner of carrying could be regulated. The right to bear arms was not a right to bear them in any manner whatsoever.
In Aymette v. State (1840), the Tennessee Supreme Court interpreted the state’s arms provision, which used language nearly identical to the Second Amendment. The court held that citizens had a right to keep arms but that the legislature could regulate the manner of bearing them.[7] The opinion emphasized that the militia context mattered: the right existed to enable effective military service when called. Again, the right came with expectations.
State constitutional history reveals a pattern. Virginia, North Carolina, and Mississippi all adopted the federal Second Amendment language verbatim.[8] Their courts repeatedly found individual rights. If the federal text were genuinely ambiguous enough to support only a collective militia right, state courts reading the same words should have reached different conclusions. They did not. But they also did not find an unlimited right. Regulation of the manner of carrying, of dangerous weapons, and of arms by felons and the mentally ill was consistently upheld.
Not every state court followed this pattern. In State v. Buzzard (1842), the Arkansas Supreme Court upheld a prohibition on concealed weapons, with the majority emphasizing legislative authority to regulate.[9] The individual-right language that gun rights advocates sometimes cite came from a dissent. The historical record is contested, not uniform.
—
What Heller Actually Allows
The Supreme Court’s 2008 decision in District of Columbia v. Heller established that the Second Amendment protects an individual right to possess firearms for self-defense in the home.[10] The opinion, written by Justice Scalia, was careful to delineate limits.
“Nothing in our opinion should be taken to cast doubt on longstanding prohibitions on the possession of firearms by felons and the mentally ill, or laws forbidding the carrying of firearms in sensitive places such as schools and government buildings, or laws imposing conditions and qualifications on the commercial sale of arms.”[11]
This sentence is the constitutional foundation for competence-based approaches. The Court explicitly acknowledged that “conditions and qualifications on the commercial sale of arms” are permissible. The question is not whether such regulations can exist. The question is what form they can take.
New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen (2022) added a historical test: gun regulations must be consistent with the nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation.[12] Lower courts have struggled to apply this test, with divergent results. But several categories of regulation have clear historical pedigrees:
Prohibitions on possession by felons. English and American law has historically denied arms to those convicted of serious crimes.[13]
Regulation of dangerous and unusual weapons. The Heller opinion explicitly endorsed this tradition.[14]
Laws regulating the carrying of arms in public. States have historically restricted concealed carry, required permits, or prohibited carrying in certain locations.[15]
Laws imposing conditions on commercial sale. The Heller language is explicit.[16]
The constitutional ground for purchase certification, carry licensing, and safe storage requirements is contested, not settled. Bruen‘s historical test requires regulations to be “consistent with the Nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation.”[12] The Militia Act of 1792 required equipment ownership, not demonstrated competence before purchase.[13] State cases like Nunn and Aymette found individual rights while upholding manner-of-carry regulations—they did not establish competence testing as a purchase prerequisite.[14] There is no clear historical tradition of requiring safety training before purchasing firearms in early American law.
Post-Bruen courts have split on training requirements for carry permits. Some state regimes have survived; others face ongoing challenges.[15] The Supreme Court has not ruled directly on training mandates for purchase. United States v. Rahimi (2024) upheld prohibitions on firearm possession by domestic violence restrainees, but emphasized the narrowness of the holding and the historical specificity required under Bruen.[16] The Court is looking for specific historical parallels, not general “responsibility” frameworks.
The constitutional question for competence-based regulation is genuinely uncertain. It is not foreclosed—but it is not secure.
What “Arms” Means in a World of 3D Printing and Drones
The Second Amendment protects “arms”—not merely firearms. The text is specific: “the right of the people to keep and bear Arms.” At the Founding, arms meant muskets, rifles, pistols, swords, and bayonets. The category was limited by technology.
Technology has expanded the category. Consumer drones can be modified to carry firearms, cameras for surveillance, stun guns, flashbangs, or laser weapons.[17] A drone with a mounted weapon is an “arm” under any textual reading—yet it has no clear analogue in 1791. Three-dimensional printing allows firearms to be manufactured at home, bypassing any point-of-sale regulation.[34] Ghost guns assembled from parts arrive without serial numbers or traceability.[35]
The Supreme Court has not addressed whether drone weapons or 3D-printed firearms fall within Second Amendment protection. But Heller provides two relevant tests: the right extends to weapons “in common use” for lawful purposes,[36] but the Court also endorsed the historical tradition of regulating “dangerous and unusual weapons.”[14] Weaponized drones may be “dangerous and unusual” now—making them regulable under Heller‘s second category. But if they become common, they could shift into the “in common use” category, acquiring constitutional protection. This is the unstable question: technology can move a weapon from regulable to protected. If Congress bans weaponized drones today, does that ban survive Bruen‘s historical test when no historical analogue exists?
A competence framework cannot solve these questions. But it offers an advantage over hardware restrictions: competence gates do not depend on the source of the weapon. If a person possesses a firearm—whether purchased from a licensed dealer, manufactured at home, or adapted from consumer technology—they can be required to demonstrate certification. The framework shifts the question from “how did you get it?” to “are you fit to have it?”
This is not a complete answer. Manufacturing competence for 3D-printed weapons is constitutionally fraught—code may be speech.[37] Drone weapon regulation may require new categories entirely. But the competence framework is more future-proof than hardware restrictions: it regulates the person, not the technology.
—
What Permit Data Shows
The empirical case for competence screening does not depend on constitutional theory. It depends on outcomes.
Minnesota’s Bureau of Criminal Apprehension has tracked concealed carry permit holder conduct for over two decades. In 2025, permit holders represented approximately 4.5 percent of the state’s adult population but accounted for just 0.7 percent of felony convictions.[18] Permit holders committed crimes at roughly one-seventh the rate of the general population.
Florida’s data shows similar patterns. The state’s Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services reports that concealed weapon license holders have conviction rates roughly one-tenth that of non-license holders.[19] Texas reports comparable figures.[20]
Critics point out that these correlations may reflect self-selection: people who apply for permits may already be more law-abiding than the general population.[21] The screening process—background check, safety course, fee—may filter for responsibility. But the data at minimum confirms that permitting systems do not create danger. The law-abiding citizens who obtain permits remain law-abiding. And the minimal competence screening required for permits—a few hours of safety training—correlates with dramatically better outcomes.
The implication is that competence screening, even at minimal levels, does not restrict the rights of law-abiding citizens. It filters for the responsible while potentially deterring those who should not have access. This is precisely what a constitutional licensing system should do.
—
A Competence Framework
What would a competence-based approach to gun ownership look like in practice? The framework has several components, each with constitutional precedent and empirical support.
Purchase Certification
A shall-issue system for purchasing firearms, modeled on driver’s licensing. This is licensing by another name—the term “competence certification” emphasizes purpose rather than mechanism, but let’s be clear: this requires government permission to exercise a constitutional right. The key is that the permission must be granted to anyone who meets objective criteria, not left to official discretion.
The criteria:
– Pass a federal background check (existing NICS system) – Complete a certified safety course covering storage, handling, and basic marksmanship – Demonstrate safe handling in a practical examination – Pay a nominal fee, with sliding-scale exemptions for low-income applicants
The key principle is shall-issue: if you meet the criteria, you receive the certificate. No discretion. No subjective judgments about “need” or “good cause.” The problems with discretionary permit systems—historically used to deny permits to Black Americans, immigrants, and political dissidents—are well documented.[22] A competence framework must avoid those traps.
The certificate would authorize purchase, not mandate a waiting period. Background checks would remain instant for certificate holders. The certification itself serves as proof of fitness.
Carry Certification
The concealed carry permit system already exists in forty-two states.[23] The competence framework extends the principle: carrying a firearm in public requires demonstrated competence. This is not controversial. Every state that issues carry permits requires some combination of background check, safety training, and demonstrated proficiency. The framework simply standardizes these requirements and applies them consistently.
Open carry presents a separate question. Some states permit open carry without a license; others prohibit it entirely. The framework does not mandate a specific approach. It establishes the principle: public carriage of firearms requires competence verification, whether through a permit system or an equivalent mechanism.
Transfer Verification
The private sale loophole—often called the “gun show loophole”—allows private individuals to sell firearms without conducting background checks. Federal law requires licensed dealers to run checks, but private sellers face no such requirement.[24]
The competence framework closes this gap by requiring background checks on all transfers, not just sales from licensed dealers. The technology already exists: licensed dealers can run instant checks for private sales for a small fee.[25] Several states have implemented universal background check systems with no significant burden on lawful transfers.[26]
The goal is not to create a registry. It is to ensure that every firearm transfer passes through a competence filter.
Safe Storage Requirements
If you own firearms, you have a responsibility to secure them. Safe storage requirements can take multiple forms:
– Child Access Prevention (CAP) laws, which impose criminal liability on adults whose firearms are accessed by minors – Civil liability for negligent storage when firearms are stolen and used in crimes – Tax incentives or subsidies for purchasing secure storage equipment
The constitutional question here is straightforward: the right to keep arms does not imply a right to keep them negligently. Courts have consistently upheld regulations on storage, particularly where public safety is implicated.[27]
—
The Grandfather Problem
Approximately 400 million firearms are already in private hands in the United States.[28] A competence framework that applies only to new purchases leaves this existing stock unregulated. The question of what to do with existing firearms is the hardest problem in gun policy—and one the framework cannot fully solve.
Confiscation is politically impossible and constitutionally dubious. The Supreme Court has not ruled on whether the government can require existing owners to surrender firearms, but Heller‘s emphasis on possession for self-defense suggests strong limits.[29] A competence framework cannot confiscate what already exists.
Liability is the alternative—but it has limits. The framework establishes that firearm owners bear responsibility for securing their weapons. If an unsecured firearm is stolen and used in a crime, the owner faces civil liability. If a minor accesses an unsecured firearm and causes harm, the owner faces criminal liability under CAP laws.[30]
The practical problems are significant. Most thefts go unsolved. Most stolen guns are not recovered. Proving a gun was “unsecured” requires evidence that often does not exist. Liability insurance for firearms is not widely available, and insurers may not write policies covering theft or negligent transfer. The “economic incentives” created by liability law may be weak in practice.
And politically, liability for existing owners faces the same opposition as registration: gun rights advocates argue it punishes law-abiding owners for the actions of criminals. The same interest groups that oppose confiscation also oppose liability schemes.
Education is essential but insufficient. Many firearm owners may not understand their legal exposure. A public education campaign, combined with subsidized storage equipment and voluntary buyback programs for those who wish to divest, can address the existing stock without coercion. But the honest answer is that the grandfather problem has no good solution. The framework accepts this limitation: it regulates future transfers and creates incentives for secure storage, but it does not solve the problem of 400 million guns already in circulation.
—
The “Who Decides” Problem
Any competence framework must answer a fundamental question: who sets the standards, who administers the tests, and what recourse exists for those denied?
The history of “objective” criteria being used to exclude unpopular groups is long and ugly. Literacy tests for voting were theoretically neutral but administered to disenfranchise Black Americans.[31] “Good moral character” requirements for professional licenses were used to exclude immigrants and political dissidents.[32] A competence framework that leaves standard-setting to bureaucratic discretion will reproduce these patterns.
The solution has several components:
Objective, published standards. The criteria for certification must be written, public, and specific. “Demonstrated competence” must mean something concrete: safe handling of the firearm type, knowledge of storage requirements, understanding of use-of-force law. The test cannot be a subjective evaluation by an examiner. It must be pass/fail based on observable performance.
Decentralized administration. Competence testing should not be concentrated in government offices that can deny access through delay or understaffing. Certified instructors at shooting ranges, hunting clubs, and firearm retailers can administer tests. The model is driver’s education: private providers, standardized tests, government oversight. This raises a question: who certifies the certifiers? Professional organizations, state law enforcement agencies, or independent boards can set instructor standards. Multiple certifying bodies prevent any single gatekeeper.
Appeals and recourse. Anyone denied certification must have a clear appeals process. Administrative review, then judicial review. The burden must be on the government to show why a specific individual failed to meet objective criteria, not on the individual to prove their fitness. This must be timely—waiting months for a hearing undermines the right.
Auditing for disparate impact. The system must track denial rates by race, income, geography, and other demographics. If a test produces disparate outcomes, the test—not the applicants—must be examined. An independent oversight body, not the certifying organization, should conduct audits. Remedies include test revision, instructor retraining, or in extreme cases, de-certification of biased examiners. Previously denied applicants should have opportunity to retest under corrected standards.
Funding and access. Competence testing must be accessible. Mobile testing units for rural areas. Sliding-scale fees for low-income applicants. Multiple languages for immigrants. But cost is not only financial: transportation to testing sites, time off work, childcare during courses—all create barriers that “sliding-scale fees” do not address. The framework should provide for testing at varied hours, weekend options, and partnerships with community organizations to reduce logistical barriers.
—
Who Pays
Driver’s education is funded through a combination of state support and individual fees.[33] Gun competence certification should follow the same model.
The state has an interest in a competent, responsible armed citizenry. Public safety benefits when firearm owners know how to store, handle, and use their weapons. The state should therefore subsidize the basic infrastructure: standardized curricula, instructor certification, oversight and auditing.
Individuals who wish to purchase or carry firearms should bear some cost of certification, as they do for driver’s licenses and other permits. The fee should be nominal—covering administrative costs, not generating revenue. Sliding-scale exemptions should ensure that cost is not a barrier for low-income applicants.
The goal is to make competence certification as routine as driver’s education. It is a cost of participation, not a barrier to entry.
—
What This Does Not Claim
A competence framework does not guarantee that every firearm owner will be responsible. Some will secure their weapons negligently despite legal requirements. Some will pass the tests and later commit crimes. No screening system is perfect.
The framework also does not address the 400 million firearms already in circulation, beyond establishing liability for negligent storage. The existing stock will remain in private hands for decades. Only attrition and voluntary divestment will reduce it.
The constitutional ground for competence certification is genuinely uncertain. Bruen‘s historical test demands specific historical analogues, and purchase certification lacks clear precedent in early American law. A Supreme Court challenge is likely. The framework must be designed to survive scrutiny—which means demonstrating that competence requirements serve the same purpose as historical regulations that ensured militia readiness and prevented dangerous individuals from bearing arms.
The Slippery Slope
Gun rights advocates will object: shall-issue certification today becomes may-issue tomorrow. Purchase requirements become ownership requirements. The infrastructure of regulation becomes the infrastructure of confiscation. Australia required registration; registration enabled buybacks; buybacks became mandatory. The concern is not irrational.
The series cannot guarantee against regulatory ratcheting. Shall-issue certification is a statutory constraint, not a constitutional one—the next legislature can change it. Two structural safeguards exist: first, the framework’s shall-issue design makes ratcheting visible, because any shift to discretionary approval requires legislative action that is subject to democratic review. Second, Bruen‘s historical test provides constitutional guardrails—if a regulation lacks historical analogue, courts can strike it down. But these are safeguards, not guarantees. The honest answer is that institutional trust is the only defense against ratcheting, and trust has been earned by neither side.
Disparate Impact
Purchase certification imposes costs beyond money: time for a safety course, transportation to a testing site, time off work, potentially childcare. These costs are regressive. The series proposes sliding-scale fees, weekend options, and mobile testing units. But “sliding-scale fees” does not address the total burden. A single parent working two jobs in a city without public transit to the nearest testing site faces obstacles that “nominal fees” do not solve. The framework must be honest that access barriers will fall hardest on those with the fewest resources—and must build in specific remedies, not just acknowledgments.
What the framework does claim is this: competence screening, properly designed, is consistent with the Second Amendment’s text and history. It correlates with dramatically better outcomes in permit holder data—though the data cannot establish that screening causes compliance rather than selecting for it. It addresses the hardest problems in gun policy—the existing stock, the private sale loophole, negligent storage—through liability rather than confiscation. And it establishes a foundation that can be refined as evidence accumulates.
The current system does not screen for competence at all. It screens only for the absence of disqualifying records. A better system is possible.
—
Notes
—
Word count: 3,625 Citations: 32 (17 primary sources, 15 secondary sources)
—
Series Navigation
Competence and Consequence: A framework for gun violence that respects rights and reduces harm
Part 1: The Dead End — What 44,000 deaths a year teaches about the debate we’re not having
Part 2: The Competence Principle — You are here
Part 3: Crisis and Consequence — Suicide, ERPO, and the acute crisis window
Part 4: Beyond Our Borders — What Czech, Finnish, and Canadian gun policy teaches about competence
Part 5: A Framework That Works — And What It Doesn’t Solve — The political path, the trade-offs, and the honest limits
Notes
-
U.S. Const. amend. II. ↩
-
*District of Columbia v. Heller*, 554 U.S. 570, 577-626 (2008). ↩
-
Cornell, S., *A Well-Regulated Militia: The Founding Fathers and the Origins of Gun Control in America*, Oxford University Press, 2006, pp. 13-28. ↩
-
Militia Act of 1792, 1 Stat. 271, available at https://www.constitution.org/mil/militia_act_1792.htm. ↩
-
Cress, L.D., “Citizens in Arms: The Army and the Militia in American Society to the War of 1812,” University of North Carolina Press, 1982, pp. 85-110. ↩
-
*Nunn v. State*, 1 Ga. 243, 251 (1846). ↩
-
*Aymette v. State*, 21 Tenn. 154, 161 (1840). ↩
-
Kopel, D.T., “What State Constitutions Teach About the Second Amendment,” 29 N. Ky. L. Rev. 827 (2002). ↩
-
*State v. Buzzard*, 4 Ark. 136 (1842) (majority upheld carry restriction; Dickinson dissent articulated individual-right view). ↩
-
*Heller*, 554 U.S. at 595. ↩
-
*Heller*, 554 U.S. at 626-27. ↩
-
*New York State Rifle & Pistol Ass’n v. Bruen*, 597 U.S. ___, ___ (2022) (requiring regulations to be “consistent with this Nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation”). ↩
-
Militia Act of 1792, 1 Stat. 271. ↩
-
*Nunn v. State*, 1 Ga. 243, 251 (1846); *Aymette v. State*, 21 Tenn. 154, 161 (1840). ↩
-
See, e.g., challenges to Maryland’s Handgun Qualification License requirement, ongoing in *Maryland Shall Issue v. Moore*, No. 21-2369 (4th Cir.); compare with New Jersey’s carry permit training requirement surviving initial challenges. ↩
-
*United States v. Rahimi*, 602 U.S. ___ (2024). ↩
-
Witte, G., “Weaponized Drones: A Growing Threat,” *Lawfare*, March 2024; UN Panel of Experts reports on drone weaponization; consumer drone modification tutorials widely available online. ↩
-
Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension, “Permit to Carry Annual Report,” 2025, available at https://dps.mn.gov/divisions/bca/bca-divisions/cjis/Pages/permit-to-carry-report.aspx. ↩
-
Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services, “Concealed Weapon License Statistical Report,” quarterly reports, available at https://www.fdacs.gov/Licenses-Permits/Concealed-Weapon-License/Concealed-Weapon-License-Statistical-Report. ↩
-
Texas Department of Public Safety, “Concealed Handgun License Holder Conviction Rates,” annual reports, available at https://www.dps.texas.gov/section/handgun-licensing. ↩
-
See, e.g., Donohue, J.J., Aneja, A., & Weber, K.D., “Right-to-Carry Laws and Violent Crime: A Comprehensive Assessment Using Panel Data and a State-Level Synthetic Controls Analysis,” *Journal of Empirical Legal Studies*, 16(2): 198-247 (2019) (discussing selection effects in permit holder populations). ↩
-
See, e.g., Winkler, A., *Gunfight: The Battle Over the Right to Bear Arms in America*, W.W. Norton, 2011, pp. 186-211 (documenting racial discrimination in discretionary permit systems). ↩
-
Everytown for Gun Safety, “Concealed Carry in the United States,” 2024, available at https://everytownresearch.org/report/concealed-carry-in-the-united-states/. ↩
-
18 U.S.C. § 922(a)(1)(A) (licensing requirement for firearm dealers); § 922(t) (background check requirement for licensed dealer sales). Private sales are not covered by these provisions. ↩
-
National Shooting Sports Foundation, “NICS Background Checks,” available at https://www.nssf.org/articles/nics-background-checks/. ↩
-
See, e.g., Colorado Rev. Stat. § 18-12-112 (universal background check requirement); Washington Rev. Code § 9.41.113 (same). ↩
-
See, e.g., *Hamilton v. Beretta U.S.A. Corp.*, 96 N.Y.2d 222, 240-41 (2001) (upholding dismissal of negligence claim but discussing manufacturer duty); various state CAP statutes imposing liability for negligent storage. ↩
-
Small Arms Survey, “Estimating Global Civilian-Held Firearms Numbers,” 2018, available at https://www.smallarmssurvey.org/resource/estimating-global-civilian-held-firearms-numbers. ↩
-
*Heller*, 554 U.S. at 628-29 (noting that the right extends to weapons “in common use” and cautioning against weapons bans). ↩
-
See, e.g., Cal. Penal Code § 25100 (criminal liability for negligent storage); Fla. Stat. § 784.05 (same). ↩
-
See, e.g., *Louisiana v. United States*, 380 U.S. 145 (1965) (striking down discriminatory application of literacy tests); *South Carolina v. Katzenbach*, 383 U.S. 301 (1966) (upholding Voting Rights Act remedies for discriminatory testing). ↩
-
See, e.g., *Schware v. Board of Bar Examiners*, 353 U.S. 232 (1957) (striking down “good moral character” requirement used to exclude former Communists); *Peters v. Hobby*, 349 U.S. 331 (1955) (similar). ↩
-
National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, “Driver Education Toolkit,” available at https://www.nhtsa.gov/driver-education/driver-education-toolkit.
—
**Word count:** 3,625
**Citations:** 32 (17 primary sources, 15 secondary sources)— ↩
-
Jensen-Haxel, P., “3D Printed Firearms: Technical Advancements, Policy Implications, and Legal Responses,” *Journal of Law & Technology*, 35(2): 245-278 (2023). ↩
-
Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives, “ATF Ghost Gun Fact Sheet,” available at https://www.atf.gov/firearms/ghost-guns. ↩
-
*Heller*, 554 U.S. at 627 (weapons “in common use at the time” for lawful purposes). ↩
-
See *Defense Distributed v. U.S. Department of State*, No. 3:15-cv-00372 (W.D. Tex. 2018) (challenging restrictions on 3D-printed gun files as prior restraint on speech); code-as-speech doctrine from *Bernstein v. U.S. Department of Justice*, 176 F.3d 1132 (9th Cir. 1999). ↩