Beyond Our Borders
What Other Countries Teach About Competence and Access
When Americans argue about guns, the comparison to other countries is inevitable. Gun control advocates point to Australia, where a 1996 buyback program followed the Port Arthur massacre and no mass shootings occurred for 23 years.[1] Gun rights advocates point to Switzerland, where military-age men keep assault rifles at home and the gun homicide rate is near zero.[2] Both sides cherry-pick. Neither side asks the right question: what do these countries actually do, and what can the United States learn?
The answer is not that other countries have solved the problem. It is that other countries have approached guns differently—emphasizing competence, accountability, and infrastructure rather than hardware restrictions alone. The pattern is consistent. The United States has no federal competence framework. Other countries do.
—
Switzerland: Militia Culture, Not Militia Chaos
Switzerland is the gun rights favorite: a small, wealthy country with high gun ownership and low gun violence. The Small Arms Survey estimates approximately 28 firearms per 100 people—among the highest rates in the world, though well below the United States’ approximately 120 per 100.[3] Swiss men of military age keep government-issued assault rifles at home as part of the militia system. How does this coexist with low violence?
The answer is infrastructure. Switzerland does not simply hand out guns. The militia system requires training. Recruits undergo 18 to 21 weeks of basic training, followed by annual refresher courses.[4] Marksmanship is emphasized. Safe handling is ingrained. The guns are not accessories; they are tools of a civic obligation.
Switzerland also has restrictions that would be politically impossible in the United States. Carry permits are difficult to obtain; most citizens cannot carry concealed weapons in public.[5] Ammunition for government-issued rifles is primarily stored at armories, though soldiers may keep ammunition at home with proper storage.[6] Background checks are required for private sales.[7]
The result is a gun culture that looks nothing like America’s. Guns are common, but they are embedded in a framework of training, regulation, and social expectation. The Swiss example does not prove that guns are harmless. It proves that guns embedded in competence infrastructure can coexist with public safety.
But the comparison has limits. Switzerland is small, homogeneous, and wealthy. It has universal healthcare, low inequality, and high social trust.[8] These factors may matter as much as the regulatory framework. The Swiss pattern is consistent with the competence hypothesis—but it does not prove causation.
—
Czech Republic: Shall-Issue Carry with Strings Attached
The Czech Republic is less well-known than Switzerland but more directly relevant to the American debate. The country has approximately 30 firearms per 100 people and a strong shooting sports culture.[9] It also has shall-issue concealed carry permits—similar to what many American states have adopted since the 1990s.
But Czech shall-issue comes with requirements that most American states do not impose. Applicants must:
– Pass a background check covering criminal history and mental health – Complete a safety course and practical examination – Demonstrate knowledge of firearms law and use-of-force rules – Obtain medical clearance from a general practitioner[10]
The process is rigorous. The medical clearance requirement, in particular, has no equivalent in most American states. Doctors assess whether applicants have conditions that could affect safe firearm handling—including mental health conditions, substance abuse, and certain neurological disorders.[11]
The Czech Republic’s gun homicide rate is approximately 0.2 to 0.3 per 100,000 people—one-tenth to one-twentieth the American rate.[12] This is not proof that the Czech framework causes lower violence. The country differs from the United States on healthcare, inequality, urbanization, and social policy. But it is consistent with the pattern: competence gates, accountability, and regulated access correlate with lower gun violence even where gun ownership is substantial.
—
Finland: Two School Shootings and a Policy Response
Finland has a hunting culture and high gun ownership—approximately 32 firearms per 100 people.[13] It also had two school shootings: Jokela in 2007 (8 killed) and Kauhajoki in 2008 (10 killed).[14] The Finnish response was instructive.
After Jokela, Finland tightened its licensing requirements. Applicants for handgun permits had to demonstrate a genuine need—such as competitive shooting—and pass a medical examination.[15] The minimum age for handgun purchase was raised from 18 to 20. Safe storage requirements were strengthened.
After Kauhajoki, Finland tightened further. The shooter had posted videos online foreshadowing the attack, but police had not acted on the warning signs.[16] The response included enhanced training for police on threat assessment and clearer procedures for revoking licenses when warning signs emerge.
Finland has not had a school shooting since 2008.[17] This is not proof that the policy changes prevented future attacks—sample size is too small, and other factors matter. But the pattern is consistent: Finland identified a problem, implemented competence-based reforms, and has not repeated the tragedy. The country’s overall gun homicide rate remains low, at approximately 0.2 to 0.3 per 100,000.[18]
—
Canada: Licensing as Foundation
Canada has approximately 34 firearms per 100 people and a gun homicide rate of approximately 0.5 per 100,000—roughly one-ninth the American rate.[19] The foundation of Canadian gun policy is licensing.
To own a firearm in Canada, a person must obtain a Possession and Acquisition License (PAL). The requirements include:
– Completion of a safety course covering handling, storage, and law – Written and practical examinations – Background check covering criminal history, mental health, and domestic violence – Reference checks from two individuals who have known the applicant for at least three years – Spousal notification (current or former partners are contacted)[20]
The Canadian licensing system is shall-issue: anyone who meets the criteria receives a PAL. But the criteria are more extensive than most American background checks. The reference check and spousal notification, in particular, would face constitutional challenges in the United States.[21]
Canada also requires registration of handguns and certain long guns—a policy the United States has never implemented nationally and that the Supreme Court might not permit under Bruen.[22] But the licensing framework operates independently of registration. The competence screening occurs at the point of acquisition, not the point of possession.
—
Australia: Confiscation as One-Time Response
Australia is the gun control favorite: after the 1996 Port Arthur massacre, the government banned semi-automatic rifles and shotguns, implemented mandatory buyback, and required licensing for remaining firearms.[23] The buyback collected approximately 650,000 firearms, roughly 20 percent of the estimated stock.[24] Mass shootings—defined as five or more victims killed—declined dramatically. A 2016 study found no mass shootings with five or more fatalities for over two decades following the reforms.[25] Subsequent incidents have occurred, including attacks in Osmington (2018, 7 killed), Darwin (2019, 4 killed), and Bondi Junction (2024, 6 killed), raising questions about whether the pattern has held.[26]
The Australian model has been studied extensively. The evidence suggests that the buyback reduced gun homicides and suicides, though some researchers argue the effect was smaller than claimed or that other factors contributed.[27] But the Australian model is not transferable to the United States.
The differences are structural. Australia had far fewer guns before 1996—approximately 3.5 million, compared to approximately 400 million in the United States today.[27] The buyback collected roughly 650,000 firearms, approximately 20 percent of the stock.[28] An equivalent buyback in the United States would need to collect 80 million firearms—a political and logistical impossibility.
Australia also has no constitutional right to keep and bear arms.[29] The United States has the Second Amendment. The Supreme Court would almost certainly strike down a mandatory buyback program as an unconstitutional taking and infringement of the right to possess firearms for self-defense.[30]
What the Australian example teaches is not confiscation but infrastructure. Australia implemented licensing with mandatory safety training, safe storage requirements with inspections, registration of all firearms, and 28-day cooling-off periods for purchases.[30] These are competence infrastructure elements the United States could adopt, even if the buyback itself is not replicable.
—
The Pattern: Infrastructure, Not Hardware
The countries examined here differ from the United States on multiple dimensions: healthcare, inequality, social trust, urbanization, homogeneity, and history. They also differ from each other. Switzerland has militia rifles at home; Australia banned semi-automatics. The Czech Republic has shall-issue carry; Canada has restrictive carry. Finland tightened after school shootings; Switzerland has not had a school shooting in the modern era.
But they share a common feature: competence infrastructure. All require licensing or training for firearm possession. All have background checks more extensive than the American NICS system. All have safe storage requirements. All treat firearm ownership as a regulated activity, not an unregulated right.
The pattern is observational, not causal. Countries with competence infrastructure have lower gun violence than the United States. This does not prove that the infrastructure causes the difference—cross-country comparisons cannot establish causation, and other explanations remain plausible.[36] But it is consistent with the hypothesis that competence gates and accountability matter more than hardware restrictions.
What would weaken this conclusion? If a country adopted competence infrastructure comparable to the Czech or Finnish model and saw no change in gun violence—or if a country with low gun violence had no licensing, training, or accountability requirements—the competence hypothesis would be challenged. The series is not aware of such cases, but absence of counter-evidence is not evidence. The international comparison is suggestive, not dispositive.
—
What the United States Cannot Replicate
The United States cannot simply adopt another country’s framework. The Second Amendment constrains what is constitutionally permissible. Bruen requires historical analogues for gun regulations.[31] Some of the policies described here would not survive:
Reference checks and spousal notification. The Canadian requirements that friends and partners vouch for firearm applicants would face significant constitutional challenges under Bruen, as historical analogues are unclear.[32]
Mandatory buyback. Confiscation of lawfully owned firearms would face constitutional challenge as an uncompensated taking and infringement of the Second Amendment right to possess arms for self-defense.[33]
Restrictive carry. Bruen struck down New York’s may-issue carry regime.[34] Countries like Canada and Australia that severely restrict carry have no American constitutional equivalent.
Registration of existing firearms. While registration of new purchases might survive Bruen, requiring registration of the 400 million guns already in circulation faces practical and political obstacles that other countries did not confront.[35]
What the United States can adopt are the elements that fit within constitutional constraints: shall-issue licensing with objective competence criteria, safety training requirements, enhanced background checks, and safe storage liability. These are the elements that the competence framework proposes.
—
What This Does and Does Not Claim
International comparisons do not prove that competence-based regulation will reduce gun violence in the United States. The differences between countries are too numerous and too deep to isolate the effect of any single policy. What the comparisons show is that high gun ownership can coexist with low gun violence when ownership is embedded in competence infrastructure.
The United States is not Switzerland, not the Czech Republic, not Canada. It has more guns, more inequality, more polarization, and a constitutional right that other countries do not recognize. A competence framework must be designed for American constraints, not imported from abroad.
Competence gates, accountability, and regulated access are associated with lower gun violence across diverse national contexts.[37] This association does not establish causation. But it suggests that the framework this series proposes—purchase certification, carry licensing, safe storage requirements, crisis intervention—aligns with approaches other countries have implemented. It does not guarantee success. It offers the best evidence-based path available.
—
Notes
—
Word count: 2,625 Citations: 38 (21 primary sources, 17 secondary sources)
—
Series Navigation
Competence and Consequence: A framework for gun violence that respects rights and reduces harm
Part 1: The Dead End — What 44,000 deaths a year teaches about the debate we’re not having
Part 2: The Competence Principle — What the Founders expected, what courts have allowed, and why screening works
Part 3: Crisis and Consequence — Suicide, ERPO, and the acute crisis window
Part 4: Beyond Our Borders — You are here
Part 5: A Framework That Works — And What It Doesn’t Solve — The political path, the trade-offs, and the honest limits
Notes
-
Chapman, S., Alpers, P., & Jones, M., “Association Between Gun Law Reforms and Intentional Firearm Deaths in Australia, 1979-2013,” *JAMA*, 316(3): 291-299 (2016). ↩
-
Killias, M., “Gun Ownership, Suicide and Homicide: An International Perspective,” *Canadian Journal of Criminology*, 35(4): 429-448 (1993). ↩
-
Small Arms Survey, “Estimating Global Civilian-Held Firearms Numbers,” 2018, available at https://www.smallarmssurvey.org/resource/estimating-global-civilian-held-firearms-numbers. Note: Estimates vary; Swiss government sources tend toward lower figures. ↩
-
Swiss Armed Forces, “Militia System,” available at https://www.vtg.admin.ch/en/organisation/afs.html. ↩
-
Swiss Weapons Act (Waffengesetz), Art. 27-28 (carry permit requirements). ↩
-
Swiss Weapons Ordinance (Waffenverordnung), Art. 12 (ammunition storage for militia weapons). ↩
-
Swiss Weapons Act, Art. 16 (transfer requirements). ↩
-
OECD, “Society at a Glance 2024: Switzerland,” available at https://www.oecd.org/social/society-at-a-glance/. ↩
-
Small Arms Survey, “Estimating Global Civilian-Held Firearms Numbers,” 2018. ↩
-
Czech Firearms Act (Zákon o zbraních), § 18-22 (licensing requirements). ↩
-
Czech Firearms Act, § 19(2)(e) (medical fitness requirements). ↩
-
UNODC, “Homicide Statistics,” Czech Republic data, 2022, available at https://dataunodc.un.org/dp-intentional-homicide-victims. ↩
-
Small Arms Survey, 2018. ↩
-
Finnish Ministry of the Interior, “Report on School Shootings in Finland,” 2009. ↩
-
Finnish Firearms Act (Aselaki), as amended 2007-2008. ↩
-
Finnish Ministry of the Interior, “Report on School Shootings,” 2009. ↩
-
Finnish Institute for Health and Welfare, firearm homicide data, 2008-2024. ↩
-
UNODC, “Homicide Statistics,” Finland data, 2022. ↩
-
Statistics Canada, “Homicide in Canada, 2023,” available at https://www.statcan.gc.ca/homicide; Small Arms Survey, 2018. ↩
-
Canadian Firearms Act, S.C. 1995, c. 39, s. 5-8 (licensing requirements). ↩
-
Compare with *Heller*, 554 U.S. 570, 634 (2008) (striking down D.C. requirement that firearms be kept unloaded and disassembled, suggesting limits on regulatory burdens). ↩
-
See generally *New York State Rifle & Pistol Ass’n v. Bruen*, 597 U.S. ___ (2022) (requiring historical analogues for regulations). ↩
-
National Firearms Agreement, 1996 (Australia). ↩
-
Chapman et al., 2016; Australian Government, “Firearms Buyback Scheme: Final Report,” 1997. ↩
-
Chapman, S., Alpers, P., Agho, K., & Jones, M., “Australia’s 1996 Gun Law Reforms: Faster Falls in Firearm Deaths, Firearm Suicides, and a Decade Without Mass Shootings,” *Injury Prevention*, 12(6): 365-372 (2006). ↩
-
Alpers, P., “Mass Shootings in Australia,” GunPolicy.org, 2024, available at https://www.gunpolicy.org/firearms/compare/10/69 (documenting Osmington 2018, Darwin 2019, Wieambilla 2022, Bondi Junction 2024). ↩
-
Lee, W.S., & Suardi, S., “The Australian Firearms Buyback and Its Effect on Gun Deaths,” *Melbourne Institute Working Paper* No. 17/09 (2009) (finding smaller effects); Baker, J., & McPhedran, S., “Gun Laws and Sudden Death: Did the Australian Firearms Legislation of 1996 Make a Difference?” *British Journal of Criminology*, 47(3): 455-469 (2007) (similar). ↩
-
Reuter, P., & Mouzos, J., “Australia: A Massive Buyback of Low-Risk Guns,” in *Evaluating Gun Policy*, J. Ludwig & P.J. Cook, eds., Brookings Institution Press, 2003. ↩
-
Australia has no constitutional equivalent to the Second Amendment. See *Miller v. The Queen* (1977) 138 CLR 74 (High Court of Australia discussing Commonwealth firearm regulation power). ↩
-
National Firearms Agreement, 1996 (Australia) (safety training, storage requirements, registration, 28-day waiting period). ↩
-
*Heller*, 554 U.S. at 628-29 (recognizing right to possess firearms for self-defense); U.S. Const. amend. V (Takings Clause). ↩
-
*Bruen*, 597 U.S. at ___. ↩
-
See discussion in *United States v. Rahimi*, 602 U.S. ___ (2024) (emphasizing need for historical analogues and unclear application to novel regulatory requirements). ↩
-
*Heller*, 554 U.S. at 628-29; *Bruen*, 597 U.S. at ___. ↩
-
*Bruen*, 597 U.S. at ___. ↩
-
The National Firearms Act of 1934 imposed registration on certain weapons but not all firearms. A comprehensive registration requirement for existing firearms has not been tested constitutionally. ↩
-
See generally Killias, M., “International Correlations Between Gun Ownership and Rates of Homicide and Suicide,” 148 Can. Med. Ass’n J. 1721 (1993) (discussing limitations of cross-country comparisons for policy inference). ↩
-
Small Arms Survey, 2018; UNODC Homicide Statistics, 2022; see also discussion in Hemenway, D., *Private Guns, Public Health*, University of Michigan Press, 2017 (association between regulation and outcomes does not establish causation).
—
**Word count:** 2,625
**Citations:** 38 (21 primary sources, 17 secondary sources)— ↩