Geofence Warrants: The Supreme Court Confronts Digital Dragnet Surveillance A six-part series on the constitutional future of mass location surveillance — On April 27, 2026, the Supreme Court will hear arguments in Chatrie v. United States—the first case to place the constitutionality of geofence warrants before the nation’s highest court. The decision will determine whether…
Month: April 2026
geofence-warrants-part6-coming-precedent
Geofence Warrants – Part 6: The Coming Precedent On April 27, the Supreme Court will hear arguments in Chatrie v. United States. The decision will not just determine whether geofence warrants are constitutional. It will define the Fourth Amendment’s relationship with mass digital surveillance for a generation. — The Supreme Court granted certiorari in Chatrie…
geofence-warrants-part5-google-policy-shift
Geofence Warrants – Part 5: Google’s 2023 Policy Shift Google announced it would stop storing location data centrally, effectively ending its role as a geofence warrant target. A year later, investigators and civil liberties groups aren’t sure the fix is real—or whether it matters. — On December 8, 2023, Google announced a policy change that…
geofence-warrants-part4-scale-problem
Geofence Warrants – Part 4: The Scale Problem In 2020, Google received 11,554 geofence warrants. Each one searched hundreds of millions of devices to find suspects who didn’t know they were being looked for. There are no statutory limits on how big the net can be. — The constitutional questions raised by geofence warrants—the particularity…
geofence-warrants-part3-grand-canyon-split
Geofence Warrants – Part 3: The Grand Canyon Split Two federal circuits. The same technology. The same constitutional amendment. Opposite conclusions. One commentator called it “the Grand Canyon of circuit splits”—but both circuits agree on the fundamentals. The disagreement is about the shape of Fourth Amendment protection, not its existence. — On August 9, 2024,…
geofence-warrants-part2-chatrie-case
Geofence Warrants – Part 2: The Chatrie Case A Virginia credit union was robbed. Police had no suspect—so they asked Google to find one. What followed was a constitutional journey through three levels of federal courts, producing a decision so fractured that 14 judges couldn’t agree on why they agreed. — On an August day…
geofence-warrants-part1-sensorvault
Geofence Warrants – Part 1: The Sensorvault Architecture Google built a database that tracks the movements of hundreds of millions of people. Law enforcement figured out how to search it in reverse—identifying suspects not by who they are, but by where their phones happened to be. — In 2020, law enforcement agencies served Google with…
A Framework That Works — And What It Doesn’t Solve
A Framework That Works — And What It Doesn’t Solve The Political Path, the Trade-Offs, and the Honest Limits Every policy proposal faces two questions: Will it work? And can it pass? The competence framework has spent four parts addressing the first question. This part addresses the second—and the honest limits of what any framework…
Beyond Our Borders
Beyond Our Borders What Other Countries Teach About Competence and Access When Americans argue about guns, the comparison to other countries is inevitable. Gun control advocates point to Australia, where a 1996 buyback program followed the Port Arthur massacre and no mass shootings occurred for 23 years.[1] Gun rights advocates point to Switzerland, where military-age…
Crisis and Consequence
Crisis and Consequence Suicide, ERPO, and the Acute Crisis Window In 2024, approximately 27,000 Americans died by firearm suicide, according to provisional CDC data.[1] That number dwarfs every other category of gun death—more than all homicides, more than all accidents and mass shootings combined.[2] And yet the gun debate focuses almost entirely on homicide, on…