Part 2 of “The Newsprint Vultures” — The $294 million pension transfer scheme, the whistleblowers who exposed it, and the Department of Labor investigation that followed.
The editor who would not stay quiet
In May 2018, Chuck Plunkett resigned as editorial page editor of The Denver Post. He hadn’t been fired. He hadn’t been laid off. He quit because his own newspaper wouldn’t publish his words.
Plunkett had written an editorial critical of Alden Global Capital, the hedge fund that owned the Post through its Digital First Media subsidiary. He’d watched as 30 of his colleagues were laid off in April — a third of the newsroom. He’d seen ownership extract profits while gutting local journalism. And when he tried to publish a follow-up editorial calling out Alden’s management, Digital First Media COO Guy Gilmore blocked it.[1]
The editorial that never ran was blunt: “A SERIOUS THREAT to journalism in Colorado and across the country is only growing stronger. Papers owned by Alden Global Capital and operated by Digital First Media now suffer not just from neglect, but outright censorship.”[2]
Plunkett’s resignation made national headlines. But the story behind his outrage — the story of how Alden had treated newspaper employees’ retirement savings as a personal investment fund — would take years to fully emerge.
The $294 million transfer
The Department of Labor investigation, concluded in 2019 but not fully reported until 2021, revealed the scale of what Alden had done: $294 million in newspaper employee pension assets had been transferred into funds controlled by Alden Global Capital itself.[3]
The victims:
| Newspaper | Pension Invested | % of Total Assets | Workers Covered |
|---|---|---|---|
| San Jose Mercury News | $106.7 million | 90% | 1,576 |
| Denver Post | $45 million | 91% | 1,812 |
At the San Jose Mercury News, 90% of the pension fund’s assets were concentrated in Alden-controlled investments. At the Denver Post, it was 91%.[4] Workers’ entire retirement savings were riding on hedge fund bets they didn’t know about and couldn’t control.
The mechanism:
Alden didn’t steal the money directly. That would have been illegal. Instead, it used a structure that was technically permitted under ERISA but violated the spirit of pension fiduciary law:
- MediaNews Group (Alden’s newspaper subsidiary) operated employee pension plans
- Plan fiduciaries — Alden-affiliated board members — directed pension investments
- Pensions were invested in “pooled funds” managed by Alden
- Alden charged management and performance fees on those investments
- The money flowed into high-risk “vulture fund” strategies
The structure had the effect of directing pension investments to Alden-controlled funds. Alden’s own employees were making investment decisions for pension plans that they also controlled.
The Cayman connection
The primary destination for newspaper pension money was AGBPI Fund Ltd., a hedge fund registered in the Cayman Islands.[5]
Ugland House — the registered address for AGBPI — is a single building in George Town, Grand Cayman, that serves as the legal home for thousands of offshore entities. Tax transparency advocates have long criticized such structures for opacity and regulatory avoidance.
In October 2015, AGBPI filed its Form D with the SEC. The filing revealed:
- Total fund assets: $257.4 million
- DFM pension investment: $236.4 million (91.8% of the fund)
- Number of investors: 9
Newspaper workers’ retirement savings made up nearly all of the fund. Alden had essentially turned employee pensions into its personal investment vehicle.[6]
The paired Global CRE Opportunities Fund, based in Delaware, invested in “legacy commercial mortgage-backed securities” — pre-2008 mortgage debt. Alden’s own portfolio manager described the strategy as “event-driven,” code for betting on distressed assets.[7]
The whistleblower
Tony Mulligan, the Newspaper Guild representative for Denver Post employees, began asking questions in 2013. He noticed that pension statements showed investments in Alden-controlled funds — funds that workers hadn’t chosen and didn’t understand.[8]
When Mulligan confronted management, he was told the investments were “diversifying.” But the numbers told a different story: the Denver Post pension plan had 91% of its assets in Alden funds. That’s not diversification. That’s concentration risk.
“I’m happy to hear that the pension trustees are diversifying the plan’s assets. Investing almost exclusively in their own hedge funds may be legal, but to me, it doesn’t appear to meet the trustee’s responsibility to diversify and act solely in the interest of the plan participants.”
— Tony Mulligan (2017)[9]
Mulligan’s persistence eventually contributed to the Department of Labor investigation. But he wasn’t alone.
Three fiduciaries, one decision
The DOL investigation named three individuals who served as plan fiduciaries while also being affiliated with Alden:
- Maziar Akram — MediaNews Group board member
- Martin R. Wade III — MediaNews Group board member
- R. Joseph Fuchs — MediaNews Group board member
All three had a duty to act solely in the interest of pension plan participants. All three sat on the MediaNews Group board while also overseeing pension investments into Alden-controlled funds.
James J. Purcell of the Labor Department’s Employee Benefits Security Administration wrote that “our investigation revealed that plan-level deliberations and investment decisions were made by Alden associates despite requirements that fiduciaries generally avoid conflicts of interest.”[10]
The 2019 resolution
The Department of Labor investigation concluded in 2019 with a settlement that was, by most accounts, lenient:
| Component | Detail |
|---|---|
| Payment | $20.7 million to pension plans |
| Purpose | Compensation for losses and missed opportunities |
| Divestment | Mandatory liquidation of all pension holdings in Alden funds |
| Future Prohibition | No future investments in Alden-sponsored funds |
| Monitoring | Cambridge Associates LLC appointed as outside consultant |
| Admission | None — Alden denied wrongdoing |
$20.7 million on $294 million in pension assets. No admission of wrongdoing. No individual penalties for the fiduciaries. The settlement required Alden to divest the pensions from its funds and appoint Cambridge Associates to monitor future investment decisions.[11]
For the workers whose retirement savings had been exposed to high-risk hedge fund strategies, there was no compensation for the anxiety, the lost opportunity, or the violation of trust.
The wider toll
The pension scheme was part of a larger pattern of extraction. While retirement savings were being redirected to Cayman Island hedge funds, Alden was also slashing newsrooms.
Bay Area News Group — the cluster that included the San Jose Mercury News, Oakland Tribune, and other papers — saw its staff shrink from approximately 380 to 160 between 2012 and 2018.[12] Neil Chase, the executive editor during this period, left to become CEO of CalMatters, a nonprofit news organization.
“Casting Alden as the Darth Vader of local news,” Chase told Poynter in 2020, was accurate — but incomplete. It wasn’t just cost-cutting. It was systematic value extraction: real estate, pension funds, management fees, staff.
Dave Krieger, editorial page editor of the Boulder Daily Camera, self-published an editorial critical of Alden after his publisher rejected it. He was fired for “insubordination.”[13] The editorial had simply called for “more responsible management.”
Between 2012 and 2019, Alden cut 71% of jobs in the hedge fund’s Guild-represented newsrooms.[14] The pension transfers were happening while newsrooms were being hollowed out.
What changed, what didn’t
After the DOL settlement, Alden sold Tribune Publishing. The pension funds were moved out of Alden-controlled investments. Cambridge Associates was appointed to monitor.
But the legal framework that allowed self-dealing in the first place remains unchanged. ERISA doesn’t prohibit companies from investing pension funds in affiliates’ products — it only requires that conflicts of interest be managed “prudently.” The standard for prudence, in practice, is low.
Chuck Plunkett never got his editorial published. Dave Krieger lost his job. Tony Mulligan’s questions took years to result in action. And the $294 million that flowed through AGBPI Fund Ltd. — the newspaper workers’ money, invested in distressed debt, managed by offshore entities — generated fees for Alden while workers watched their retirement savings ride hedge fund volatility.
What comes next
Part 3: The Profitability Paradox — Why Digital First Media showed profits while newsrooms collapsed.
How could newspapers generate “jaw-dropping profits” while cutting 70% of staff? The answer lies in the financial engineering that turned journalism businesses into extraction machines.
Notes
- Hutchins, Corey, “Rejected Denver Post editorial decries ‘outright censorship’ at Digital First papers,” Columbia Journalism Review, May 7, 2018. https://www.cjr.org/united_states_project/denver-post-digital-first-media.php
- Plunkett, Chuck, suppressed editorial text, April 2018, published in Columbia Journalism Review.
- The Seattle Times, “The hedge fund set to buy Tribune Publishing mismanaged employees’ pensions, federal investigators found,” April 23, 2021. https://www.seattletimes.com/business/the-hedge-fund-set-to-buy-tribune-publishing-mismanaged-employees-pensions-federal-investigators-found/
- Reynolds, Julie, “Newspaper chain DFM invests millions of pension dollars with its hedge-fund owner,” DFMworkers.org, 2017. https://dfmworkers.org/newspaper-chain-dfm-invests-millions-of-pension-dollars-with-its-hedge-fund-owner/
- Securities and Exchange Commission, Form D Notice of Exempt Offering, AGBPI Fund Ltd., filed October 9, 2015. Accession No. 0000902595-15-000017.
- Reynolds, Julie, DFMworkers.org, 2017.
- Alden Global Capital press release, November 2015, quoted in DFMworkers.org.
- NewsGuild-CWA, “Under federal investigation, Alden pulls half its proposed Gannett takeover slate,” 2019. https://newsguild.org/under-federal-investigation-alden-pulls-half-its-proposed-gannett-takeover-slate/
- Mulligan, Tony, quoted in DFMworkers.org, 2017.
- Purcell, James J., Employee Benefits Security Administration, DOL Decision Letter to Alden Global Capital, 2019. Reported in The Seattle Times, April 23, 2021.
- U.S. Department of Labor, Employee Benefits Security Administration, 2019 Decision Letter to Alden Global Capital, obtained via FOIA.
- Point Reyes Light, reporting on Neil Chase and Bay Area News Group decline, 2025.
- DFMworkers.org, Krieger firing documentation.
- Jacobson, Savannah, “The most feared owner in American journalism looks set to take some of its greatest assets,” Columbia Journalism Review, June 11, 2020. https://www.cjr.org/special_report/alden-global-capital-medianews-tribune-company.php
This article is part of the “Newsprint Vultures” series, investigating the financial destruction of local journalism. Part 3 examines why Digital First Media showed profits while newsrooms collapsed.